If all your inputs to the ballistics calculator are correct (mass, velocity, BC and sight over bore most important) you should be pretty close. You need to make sure that your scope crosshairs are level to the scope base and that the crosshairs are level when you adjust your zero. Most calculators probably do not include spin drift, but that is not likely to be a large factor at 500y.
Maybe we are saying the same thing, but you do not want your scope showing high at 100, you want your POI 7.5" high at 100 yards.
Maybe we are saying the same thing, but you do not want your scope showing high at 100, you want your POI 7.5" high at 100 yards.